Article first published as Blu-ray Review: 'The Rooftop' on Blogcritics.
If you think the musical and kung fu genres would make a good
pairing, well you’d be wrong. While I’ve always considered them to be
genre brethren, I think Jay Chou may have been the wrong person to
develop the first of its kind. Just check out the opening scene of
Stephen Chow’s Kung Fu Hustle to see who probably should have
been responsible for this kind of film. In the end, Jay Chou only proves
that he does have the requisite expertise behind the camera, but he
sure lets the shenanigans of The Rooftop get too out of control
by the end of its runtime. However, anyone looking for the next Baz
Luhrman-wannabe make sure you grab your copy of The Rooftop on Blu-ray December 10.
In
the mystical world of Galilee City, Wax (Chou) literally lives on a
rooftop. Along with the rest of the community, they spend their time
singing and dancing with no worries to trouble them. Wax has friends in
the form of mother-figure Jasmine (Xu Fan), A-Lang (A-Lang), Egg (Devon
Song), and Tempura (Alan Ko). Tempura is the only one who holds a real
job working for Rango (Wang Xueqi) who leads the City Housing Authority
triad, collecting rent from the town’s merchants. Wax literally runs
into the love of his life, Starling (Li Xin’ai), after he tries to save
her from William (Darren Chiu), during the filming of a movie scene.
Soon enough, Wax is swept into the movie life as a stunt double, while
trying to woo Starling, who is under the watchful eye of her father Lao
Li (Kenny Bee) and is using his daughter to make money to pay back some
debt. Everything comes to a head as storylines collide in a weirdly
violent finale.
Well Go USA is getting pretty consistent in their video department. The Rooftop
tries to dazzle with its visual flair, but a cranked up contrast level
washes out a lot of fine detail. Colors pop for the most part, but the
contrast inconsistency makes most of them bloom and bleed. The 2.35:1
aspect ratio could have looked a lot better had they toned this issue
down and involved at least one scene with a true level of black. The 5.1
DTS-HD Master Audio track on the other hand is exactly what you’d
expect from a musical action film. Surrounds are fully active with
dialogue crisp and clean. Musical numbers are typically full of deep
LFE, and the city scape comes to life whenever they venture out from
their rooftop home. At least the film sounds better than it looks. I’ve
read a report of people having issues with their Blu-ray playback and
wanted to report that I had absolutely none. The only special feature is
the film’s trailer, even though this is the kind of film that they
would have been completely welcomed to see some of the behind-the-scenes
involved with shooting the dance numbers.
You’d expect a certain level of violence — even if mostly playful — in a film as wildly over-the-top as The Rooftop
tries to be. Unfortunately, Chou takes a turn for the worst in the
final act as he involves some heavy gunplay and a scene of attempted
rape. Of course Wax swoops in to save the day, but the film is bookended
with an unnecessary plot device where he tries way too hard to make his
audience cry. As soon as a vital plot point unveils itself you can see
where it’s headed a mile away. Chou does have a pretty good visual eye
and stages some elaborate musical sequences, but the story is far too
childish to make up for the last quarter of the runtime. And at 122
minutes, The Rooftop is way too long and a huge chore to sit through.
No comments:
Post a Comment